Sour beer, and sandwiches, and ice cream – oh my! We recently dove into all that Pretentious Barrel House has to offer for a well-rounded evening: a flight of Pretentious sour beer, pressed snacks and sandwiches from the Moody Trudy Food Truck, a flight of Indulgence ice cream for dessert, and plenty of bar games to play!

Prententious Barrel House 2

Not into sour beer? Neither was I before I visited Pretentious Barrel House over a year ago. Now I almost exclusively drink sour beer and I’ve never looked back. Making exclusively sour beer, chances are they have one that appeals to your taste buds. And like I mentioned they have flights available to make sampling even easier. So hang out and sip for awhile.

Pretentious Barrel House was the first sour focused brewery in central Ohio, but they took it a step further because their sours are also barrel aged. Their hard work has paid off because their Magnanimous sour won Best in Show this year out of 400 beers at the Ohio Brewers Cup! As in best beer overall, not just sours.

Pretentious Barrel House 3

The weather may not be very favorable to enjoying their patio these days, but thankfully there are plenty of games (and a skee-ball league!) to be played inside and hot food available from the unapologetically delicious Moody Trudy Food Truck.

Moody Trudy Food Truck 3

Trudy is passionate about food and it it shows. From snacks and dips to sandwiches and soups, I’ve loved everything I’ve ever had but my new favorite is the jackfruit, which is a testament to her goal to accommodate every eater. When she is not at Pretentious, you can find her fare inside The Shrunken Head in Italian Village every Thursday.

Moody Trudy Food Truck 1

Moody Trudy Food Truck 5

Moody Trudy Food Truck 4

You can’t have a meal without dessert, so why not order some ice cream that can only be found at Pretentious? While you can find Indulgence Ice Cream at various restaurants in town (La Tavola, The Old Spot, etc), there are flavors made with Pretentious sour beer that you can only get here! Proclaimed as the best in town by almost everyone who has tried it (including myself), Indulgence Ice Cream has a real stake in the Columbus ice cream scene.

Pretentious Indulgence Ice Cream

We were treated to one-time-only ice cream flights, so don’t try to order that, but you can order single servings (or two if you’re a sharer) anytime. Watch Indulgence Ice Cream’s IG or Facebook for new flavors at Pretentious and around town. You can even request special orders if you’re nice ;-).

Pretentious Indulgence Ice Cream Flavors

Quite the lovely evening if I do say so myself. If I lived closer I would be there much more often and be a lot poorer.

Pretentious #cbusfoodbloggers

@whereshouldweeat_cbus – @614sustenance – @columbusfoodtroll – @brunchnbreweries – @cbuslocallove – @samsaysyum – @tasting.with.tina – @spiffycolumbus – @midwest_foodfest

So many reasons to check out Pretentious if you haven’t done so already. You could even host a party in their space!

Pretentious Barrel House
745 Taylor Avenue
Columbus, OH 43219
Phone: (614) 887-7687
Monday-Tuesday: CLOSED
Wednesday-Friday: 4-10pm
Sunday: 12-8pm

Moody Trudy Food Truck

Indulgence Ice Cream

Interested in collaborating on a meetup or becoming a member of the Columbus Food Bloggers group? Please email us at:

Blog Post by:  
Erin, The Spiffy Cookie

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.